Minutes from NAHCA Division 12 General Meeting
November 17, 2001
1. Meeting called to order at 10:50 am.
Location: Battleship Massachusetts, Fall River, MA
2. Roll Call:
Voting Members:
Fleet 28       Doreen Coughlan
Fleet 136     Joe Manganello
Fleet 154     Eric Anderson
Fleet 209     John Decker
Fleet 231     Greg Harwood
Fleet 448     Tony Ramos
Fleet 496     John Swiniarski
Fleets not represented: 31, 56, 143, 186
A quorum was established.

Division Officers:

Chair                  Dave Heroux
Vice Chair          Tom Therrien
Secretary           Mike Levesque
Treasurer:          Mike Ferrara, (Not Present)

Other members present:

Rick Bliss (154)

Frank Keefe (154)
Ted Knowlton (28)
Michelle McLean (448)
Todd Riccardi (28)
John Smith (448)
Phil Vallaincourt (154)
Nancy Worth (28)
3. Chair’s Report (Dave Heroux)
Racing attendance report.  Attendance decreasing.

Division Book report. 500 printed, 452 mailed.
Cost $1300, targeted income $1675.
More discussion in new business.

Review of NAHCA AGM in Tampa, discussion of Open Class issues.
Discussion of NAHCA Youth Dragoon program. 
4. Secretary’s Report (Mike Levesque)
The minutes from the 2000 meeting, prepared by Barbara Lemme, were read.
Motion:“Approve 2000 Division 12 General Meeting minutes as presented.”
Made by Eric Anderson, seconded by Greg Harwood.
Motion passed unanimously.
Approved 2000 minutes will be e-mailed to the fleets.

5. Treasurer’s Report (Mike Ferrara)
Not Present.
6. Scorekeeper’s Report (Mike Levesque)
2001 final results are in progress.Will e-mail and post on website.
Mike Levesque and Michelle McLean donating trophies to top 3 boats of Hobie 14, Hobie 16 and Distance Multihull classes from Sail for Pride (Newport, RI).Trophies not ready for meeting, will distribute later.
7. Membership Report (Dave Heroux)
117 Racers in 2001.
Distribution list for 2002 Division book: 330 (based on 2000 and 2001 attendees).
8. Appeals Committee Report (Dave Fortier)
Not Present.
Dave Heroux noted that the Rick Pineau / Dino Garbero matter was settled with a US Sailing judge.Dino Garbero prevailed.
9. Website Report (Ted Knowlton)
New address to simplify website: www.hobie-div12.org
Seeking more content, fresh ideas.
10.  Fleet Reports
Fleet 28: 40 members, 2 meetings
Newsletter: The Mainsheet, Jim Riddle, 2 issues
Website: Ted Knowlton
Boat Show: Boston, MA show not attended in 2001, perhaps in 2002.
2nd Learn-to-Sail (with Boston Ski & Sports Club) was held in 2001, looking to grow in 2002.
Buzzard regatta may consider 3-day event, GEP, location change.
Winter workshops planned for tactics, rules, etc.Starting in Feb 2002.

Fleet 136: 30 members, 1 meeting

Newsletter: None
Website: Todd Riccardi
Boat Show: None
Fleet heavily promotes Youth Sailing through program with town (Madison, CT).
Strong interest in Dragoon program.
Local Wednesday racing series is very successful, monohulls are also welcome.

Fleet 154: 20 members, 2 meetings

Newsletter: Barry Moore, E-mailed, 3 issues
Website: Barry Moore
Boat Show: Hartford, CT show no longer held.
Sakonnet regatta looking at new site.
Newport 100 race may return to 1 day, around Aquidneck format.
NE100 will be held in 2002.

Fleet 209: 15-20 members, 1 meeting

Newsletter: Craig Hackett, 1 issue

Website: John Decker
Boat Show: None
Will continue to host Pine Point, NH State regattas.
Sebago, ME fun racing series will also continue.

Fleet 231: 6 members, no meetings

Newsletter: None

Website: None
Boat Show: None
Local Hobie dealer referring new members.
Local sailing lessons starting.
Portland YC may have interest in Youth Program.

Fleet 448: 82 members, 7 meetings

Newsletter: The Pirates’ Den, Mark & Michelle Wood, seven issues

Website: under reconstruction
Boat Show: Providence, RI show attended in 2001, will repeat in 2002.
68 Hobies in Fleet.
Fleet hosts Quonset Point regatta and 9 Fun Days.
Learn to Sail class has 22 students in 2001.
Pro-Am event held in 2001, will expand for 2002 to help newer racers.
Strengthening ties into Newport, RI with Frostbite Series and Sail for Pride event.

Fleet 496: 12 members, 3 meetings

Newsletter: None

Website: Brandy Wood
Boat Show: None
Fleet regrouping and building.
Hampton regatta to be held in 2002.
Jeff Brunelle working hard on sponsors and promotion for regatta.
Michelob Cup will have more structured learn-to-sail, Jeff Brunelle to chair.

11. Points Regatta Schedule:
June 8-9 Sakonnet Challenge
June 22-23 Hampton Beach
July 13-14 Buzzard
Aug 3-4 Pine Point (Division 12 Champs)
Aug 10-11 RI Summer Classic

Aug 24-25 Shellfish Festival

Sept 7-8 NH State Champs

Sept 21-22 Roton Point Fall Regatta

Results of Roll Call Vote for 2002 Division 12 Championship:

Events bidding: RISC, Pine Point, Hampton

28  Pine Point

136  RISC
154  Pine Point
209  Pine Point
231  Pine Point
448  RISC
496  Hampton

Other events:
May 25-26 Michelob Cup / Learn-to-Sail
July 6-7 Lipton Cup (Alter Cup Area A: Rep: Jim Zellmer)
July 20-21 New England 100
Aug 24-25 Alter Cup Area B: Rep: Joe Manganello (at Shellfish Festival)
November 9 Division 12 General Meeting

12. Old Business (Bylaws Committee):
The Bylaws Committee in 2000 cleaned up the bylaws, now they need to be updated and reviewed for appropriateness.
John Decker will Chair the committee.Mike Levesque offered to assist as Division Secretary.Fleets were polled for additional assistance.
28 Doreen Coughlan
136 Joe Manganello
154 Pass
209 John Decker
231 Greg Harwood
448 Tony Ramos
496 John Swiniarski

13. New Business:
1.Race Committee Seminar:
Mike Levesque volunteered to host a Division-wide RC Seminar in the spring.Nancy Worth volunteered to co-host.It can be a one- or two-day course, may be coordinated with Frostbite Series.Funds needed for copies, etc.Event fee to be determined by hosts (to potentially cover lunch, etc.).
Motion: “Establish a one day Division 12 RC Seminar, to be hosted by Mike Levesque and Nancy Worth.”
Made by Joe Manganello, seconded by John Decker.
Further discussion was held and Joe Manganello withdrew the motion.

Motion:“Allocate up to $75 to for materials, etc. to support the 2002 Division 12 RC Seminar.Event hosts will determine location and other details.”

Made by Tony Ramos, seconded by Eric Anderson.

Motion passed unanimously.

2.Automatic NAHCA Area Championship Points:

Mike Levesque asked if the points for the NAHCA Area Championship could automatically be brought into the Division 12 series points without requiring the sailors to petition for them each year (the points are worth 1.5 normal value).This would make life easier for the sailors and Scorekeeper; as well as bring additional notice to these events, increase participation, etc.Currently, the Area Championship for Division12 is the Northeast AC (the Madcatter regatta in Syracuse, NY).Recently, it was the Atlantic Coast AC (last held in Wildwood, NJ).Also discussed was the option of the sailors to petition for a different regatta’s points to override their results at the AC.

Motion:“Results from the NAHCA Area Championship for Division 12 shall be counted in the annual Division 12 Series Points without action by the sailors.Current D12 rules regarding outside regattas remain intact (The regatta shall serve as the sailor’s single outside regatta to count for points, and shall count as 1.5 times normal value, based on finish position and the Division 12 prorated points table.). A sailor may petition to substitute a different outside regatta if his results would be improved, following deadlines as published in the Division 12 Series Points Rule Book.”

Made by Eric Anderson, seconded by Joe Manganello.

Yeah: 28, 136, 154, 448, 496.Abstain: 209, 231.Motion passed.

3.Status of NAHCA Atlantic Coast Area Championship:

Mike Levesque asked if any Division 12 Fleets were interested in reviving the NAHCA Atlantic Coast Area Championship.A three day event is not required.However, the three day format is an excellent opportunity to participate in the NAHCA Guest Expert Program, host an Race Committee Seminar, have a Youth or Women’s event, etc.Fleet 28 indicated that they may be interested and would pursue options.

4.Points for One-Design Classes Sailing in Open Class:

Mike Levesque noted that several times each season, there are boats that have enough boats for a one-design class at some regattas, but have to race Open Class in others.For Hobies, we have been pulling the results from the Open Class and awarding points in both the Hobie class and the Open Class.If there are two Hobie 17s in an Open Class, they are scored as 1 and 2 in the Hobie 17 class for series points for that regatta (the Open Class results are not changed).The question is: Do we want to do the same for the non-Hobie classes (particularly the Inter 20NA class)?

Motion:“For the purpose of Division 12 Series Points, each boat class with separate one-design class results in at least one regatta per season, regardless of manufacturer, shall be scored in the Open Class, as well as a separate one-design class.The points awarded for the one-design class shall be based on the number of the boats of the same one-design type racing in the Open Class at the regatta.”

Made by John Decker, seconded by Tony Ramos.

Further discussion was held and John Decker withdrew the motion.

Motion:“The Bylaws Committee will formulate a rule to address this issue.The rule must be presented to and approved by the Fleets prior to the first regatta of the 2002 season.”

Made by Eric Anderson, seconded by Ted Knowlton.

Motion passed unanimously.

5.Points for Single Hobie in Open Class:

Mike Levesque noted that there is no provision in the prorated points table for a single boat at a regatta.Currently, if Hobies are forced to race in Open Class due to having insufficient boats at the regatta, the Hobies are awarded points in their one-design class.If only one Hobie is present, there are no points available per the points table.This does not reward the sailor for attending the regatta.Much discussion was held on amount of points to reward, etc.

Motion:“Update the prorated points table for 2002 to award 10 points to a single boat at a regatta.”

Made by Rick Bliss, seconded by Greg Harwood.

Yeah: 28, 136, 209, 231, 448, 496.Nay: 154.Motion passed.

6.Status of Hobie 16 A, B, C Classes:

Mike Levesque noted that there has been a significant drop in the number of Hobie 16s at regattas, and there are not enough boats to support three fleets (A, B, C).Other Divisions have the same issue.The A, B, and C fleets are a luxury, intended to promote sailors to improve in like-ability subclasses, but are not required (no other boats have ability-dependent fleets).Much discussion was held on the issue.

Motion:“Starting in 2002, there will be two Hobie 16 fleets in Division 12, 16A and 16 Novice.The Hobie 16 class sailors shall be responsible for assigning sailors to the appropriate fleet based on ability.The A, B, C fleets may be reinstated in the future if participation warrants.”

Made by Doreen Coughlan, seconded by Eric Anderson.

Motion passed unanimously.

7.Division Book Advertisements:

Dave Heroux reviewed the policy adopted by the Division 12 officers for the 2001 Division book.No policy changes for 2002 were planned.

Sponsors:

Full page:$125

Half page:$75

Fleets:

Regatta:Boat fees ($2 per boat)

All others:$50 per page

8.New Deadline for Appeals and Protests:

Dave Heroux noted that appeals and protests should be filed by the end of the year so changes to results can be included in the Division book.This particularly applies to appeals to the series points as distributed via e-mail or on the Division 12 website.

Motion:“Starting for the 2002 season:
A. All protests and appeals shall be filed by December 31 of the year of the regatta in question.
B. The Division 12 Series Points results shall be compiled and posted on the Division 12 website by November 30.”

Made by Eric Anderson, seconded by Doreen Coughlan.

Motion passed unanimously.

9.New Procedure for Transfer of Perpetual Trophies:

Dave Heroux noted that the perpetual trophies are difficult to retrieve and transfer to the next winner each season.Much discussion was held on when to turn over, etc.

Motion:“All 2000 winners shall return the trophies to the Division Chair by May 1, 2002.Starting for the 2002 season, the perpetual trophies will be awarded to the winners of the prior season at the first regatta of the new year.The trophies are to be returned to the Division Chair by May 1 of the following year.For example, the winner of the Hobie 18 class for the 2001 season will receive the trophy at the first regatta in 2002, and return it to the Division Chair by May 1, 2003.”

Made by Eric Anderson, seconded by Doreen Coughlan.

Motion passed unanimously.

It was further recommended that this rule be marked on the rear of the trophies to facilitate this changeover.

10.Publication of Hobie 14 Frostbite Results in Division Book:

Dave Heroux mentioned that several people asked if the results of the Hobie 14 Frostbite Series could be included in the Division book.

Motion:“Starting in 2002, the Hobie 14 Frostbite Series results shall be printed in the Division book.”

Made by Eric Anderson, seconded by Tony Ramos.

Motion passed unanimously.

11.Division Website Ideas:

Ted Knowlton asked for more ideas to place on website.A suggestion was made to update the front page (add new pictures).

12.Division 12 Policy on Crew Weight Correction Factors for Open Class:

Mike Levesque mentioned that there was debate over the use of the use of Portsmouth crew weight correction factors for calculating Open Class results.Sailors from other NAHCA Divisions brought this to our attention, as they are not accustomed to using the correction.We need a Division-wide rule to be published and implemented the same way at all Division 12 points regattas.Eric Anderson and Rick Bliss gave a detailed history on the so-called “Fat Boy” rule, including pros and cons.

Motion:“Starting in 2002, Portsmouth crew weight correction factors
will NOT be used when calculating Open Class results at Division 12 points regattas.”

Made by John Decker, seconded by Rick Bliss.

Yeah: 136, 154, 209, 231, 448, 496.Nay: 28.Motion passed.

13.Division 12 Banner:

It was asked if the Division website address could be added to the Division 12 banner. It was noted that the banner was in rough shape and may be AWOL.

Motion:“Allocate up to $200 to design and fabricate a new Division 12 banner, and include the website address on the banner.”

Made by Eric Anderson, seconded by Tony Ramos.

Motion passed unanimously.

14. 2002 Division 12 Officer Elections:
1.Chair: Dave Heroux (uncontested)
2.Vice-Chair: Tom Therrien (uncontested)
3.Secretary: Mike Levesque (uncontested)
4.Treasurer: Patricia Alexander (decided as follows)
Nominations for Treasurer:

Todd Riccardi Joe M / Ted K. (disallowed by Chair due to age)
Patricia Alexander Rick B / John Sw (not present)
Doreen Coughlan Tony R / Joe M. (did not accept nomination)
Mike Ferrara Eric A / Rick B (not present)

Results of Roll Call Vote for 2002 Treasurer:

28 Patricia Alexander

136 Mike Ferrara
154 Patricia Alexander
209 Patricia Alexander
231 Patricia Alexander
448 Patricia Alexander
496 Patricia Alexander

15. 2002 Division 12 Appointed Positions:
1.Webmaster: Ted Knowlton
2.Appeals Chair: Eric Anderson
3.Scorekeeper: Mike Levesque
4.Youth Coordinator: Todd Riccardi
5.Membership Dave Heroux

16. Next Meeting:  Saturday, November 9, 2002.
17. Meeting Adjourned at 3:00 pm.
Respectfullly submitted,
Mike Levesque